Judicial oligarchy in the united states of america
Abstract
When appointing Supreme Court justices, the American President often prioritizes political considerations and personal loyalty, alongside geographical, racial, and religious factors, in order to appeal to various electoral groups. Legal qualifications, by comparison, have historically been of secondary importance. With the onset of the American Civil War, a new influential class emerged wealthy businessmen who sought to safeguard their economic interests. To protect these privileges, they began to influence state institutions, most notably the Supreme Court. During this period, the Court adopted constitutional interpretations grounded in natural law and capitalist philosophy. This group came to be labeled the "judicial oligarchy" , a term describing the dominance of judicial actors aligned with powerful economic forces. Their influence eventually provoked resistance from both the government and the public, pressuring the Court to shift its stance and embrace a more liberal and socially responsive approach. This shift marked the beginning of the end of the judicial oligarchy era, which lasted from 1861 to 1937.
References
- - Zudin .Aleksei Iu., Oligarchy as a Political Problem of Russian Post communism, (Vol. 39, No. 3,Sociological Research journal |2000).
- - Mason, Alpheus, politics and the supreme court:president Roosevelts proposal ,(Vol. 85, No. 7, University of Pennsylvania Law Review and American Law Register | 1937).
- - Morask. Bryon J. , The Politics of Supreme Court Nominations: A Theory of Institutional Constraints and Choices, (Vol. 43, No. 4, American Journal of Political Science |1999).
- - Smith. Christopher E., The Supreme Court's Emerging Majority: Restraining the High Court or Transforming Its Role ,(Vol. 24, Akron law journals | 2015).
- - Gill. Christopher, The History of the US Supreme Court, 1787–1937, (gilder lehrman institute of American history | 2023.)
- - Kosař .David, Comparative court-packing ,(Vol. 21, No.1, International Journal of Constitutional Law | 2023).
- - Latham. Earl, The Supreme Court as a Political Institution , (Vol.31,No.3, journal of the state bar association | 1947).
- - A. Lopez. Eduard, Constitutional Background to the Social Security Act of 1935 ,(Vol. 50, No. 1,Social Security Bulletin journal | 1987).
- - Tzivia. Eleni, the power of the few the idea of the oligarchy in the Thucydidean world, (Doctoral thesis submitted to University of Palermo | 2020).
- - A.Young. Ernest, Does the supreme court follow the economic Returns? A Response to amacrotheory of the court .(Vol. 58, No. 7 ,Duke Law Journal | 2009).
- - E. Roe. Gilbert, our judicial oligarchy ,(published by B.W. Huebsch New York ,united states of America | 1912).
- - Unah. Isaac, The Supreme Court in American Politics ,(published by Palgrave Macmillan, New York, United States | 2009).
- - F. Couch .Jim, NEW DEAL AGRICULTURAL APPROPRIATIONS: A POLITICAL INFLUENCE ,(Vol.24,No.2, Western Economic Journal | 1998).
- - Q. Barrett .John, Attribution Time: Cal Tinney’s 1937 Quip A Switch in Time’ll Save Nine ,(Vol. 73,No.2, Oklahoma Law Review journal | 2021).
- - Strother. Logan, & Gadarian. Shana, Public Perceptions of the Supreme Court: How Policy Disagreement Affects Legitimacy ,(Vol. 20, No. 1, The Forum journal | 2022).
- - Tushnet. Mark, The Hughes Court and Radical Political Dissent: The Case of Dirk De Jonge and Angelo Herndon .(Vol. 28, No. 2, Georgia State University Law Review | 2012).
- - Hakim. Muhammad, Immature Politicians and Oligarchy As a Threat to Democracy ,(FIAT JUSTISIA Faculty of Law journal | 2017).
- - Kelly. Nathan, The Politics of Oligarchy, (SSRN Electronic journal | 2014).
- - T. spiller. Pablo, & Rafaelgely, strategic judicial decision making, (No.w13321, NBER working paper series | 2007).
- - Hodde .Richardr, Six Notions of Political and the United States Supreme Court ,(Vol. 22, No. 1, Williams British Journal of Political Science | 1992).
- - A. Dahl. Robert, Decision making in a democracy :the supreme court as a national policy maker, (Vol.70,No.1, the American political journal , | 1976)
- - Kahn. Ronald, The Supreme Court, Constitutional Theory and Social Change ,(Vol. 43.No.3,Journal of Legal Education | 1993).
- - Molle .Rune, The return of oligarchy elite power in an age of inequality Stahl ,(The Road to Global Inequality, Aarhus, Denmark | 2016).
- - Novozhilov. Veniamin, Oligarchy as a political regime in Aristotle and in Contemporary Politics ,(Bachelor’s Thesis submitted to CHARLES UNIVERSITY | 2022).
- - Hixson. Walter, The1938 Kentucky Senate Election: Alben Barkley, the New Deal & the Defeat of Governor A.B. Happy" Chandler, (thesis presented to the faculty of the department of history western Kentucky university | 1981).
- - R. Huhn .Wilson, In Defense of the Roosevelt Court ,(Vol. 2 و No. 1 , Florida A & M University Law Review | 2007).
- Arabic References
- Books:
- - Al-Baz. Ali, supervision of the Constitutionality of Laws in Egypt and Arab and Foreign Constitutional Systems, (Egyptian Universities House, Alexandria, Egypt | 2001(.
- - Al-Shukri. Ali, The Philosophy of Amending the Constitution, (1st edition, Zein legal Publications, Beirut, Lebanon | 2022).
- - Al-Tabtabai. Adel, Constitutional restrictions between the Legislative and Judicial Powers, (1st edition, Authorship, Definition and Publishing Committee, Kuwait University, Kuwait | 2000).
- - Fawzi. Hisham, supervision of Constitutional Laws between America and Egypt, (Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, Egypt | 2006).
- - Madani. Mahmoud, The Role of the Constitutional Judiciary in Clarifying Constitutional Concepts, (Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, Egypt | 2016).
- Theses:
- - Jassim. Alaa, the constitutional restrictions of the legislator’s authority to regulate public rights and freedoms, (Master’s thesis (University of Baghdad College of Law, Iraq | 2019).
- - Al-Obaidi. Issam, supervision of the Constitutionality of Laws, (Doctoral thesis University of Mosul, Iraq | 2007).
- Published legal Research:
- - Khalid. Hamid, The Supreme Court and its role in building and protecting the constitutional system in the United States of America (Journal of Legal Sciences, Volume 27, Issue 1, University of Baghdad College of Law, Iraq | 2012).
- - Al-Shabani. Magdy, The Political Role of the Constitutional Judge (Issue 1, Maalem Journal for Legal and Political Studies, Algeria | 2017).
- - Abbas. Asim, Features of the American Judicial System and Justifications for Forming the Supreme Court in 1789, (Volume 7, Issue 1, Journal of the Babylon Center for Humanitarian Studies, Iraq | 2017).
- - Ali. Nasr, Judicial Authority Appointments in the United States of America, (Issue 56, Journal of International Studies, Iraq | 2013).
- - Miqdad, Hussein Ahmed, The Normative Theory of the Political Role of the Constitutional Judge, (Volume 2, Issue 2, Law Journal, Alexandria, Egypt | 2018).
- Constitutions:
- - The Constitution of the United States of America of 1789, amended in 1992 in force.
- Websites :
- The US Supreme Court website https://supreme.justia.com/cases
Identifiers
Download this PDF file
Statistics
Copyright and Licensing

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.


