principle of equality among creditors / an analytical study in civil law

Section: Article

Abstract

The principle of equality among creditors is deemed to be one of the most essential principles in the civil law, due to the axial role it plays in achieving justice and distributing the assets and property of the debtor on the creditors. The problem of the current study lies at the fact that Iraqi legislator in article 260 of the civil law, organized the matter of the general guarantee for the ordinary creditors. He as well established the principle of absolute and definite equality of all those creditors. However, this equality is marred by the imprecision, as he determined some exceptional cases that guarantee the preference and priority of some of those creditors. Moreover, the ordinary creditor may in specific conditions, occupy a privileged legal status in which he can obtain his debt without competition from the creditors and undermines it. This present research paper has been structured it in two sections, The first is titled as the concept of the principle of the equality among the creditors, Whereas the second one deals with the legal application for that principle and the exceptions on it. the study has suggested the article (260) to be amended as recommended, in addition to regulating and codifying the cases in which the creditor can gain his or her right by priority.

References

  1. References
  2. First: Dictionaries:
  3. Al-Jurjani, Ali ibn Muhammad, Definitions (Dar Al-Fadila, Cairo 1413 AH).
  4. Arab Encyclopedia Commission, Specialized Legal Encyclopedia, vol 6 (Damascus 2010).
  5. Arabic Language Academy, Philosophical Dictionary (General Authority for Government Press Affairs, Cairo 1983).
  6. Saliba, Jamil, Philosophical Dictionary, vol 2 (Dar Al-Kitab Al-Lubnani, Beirut 1982).
  7. Second: Legal Books
  8. Abdel-Baqi, Abdel-Fattah, Lectures on the Rules of Obligations (Nahdat Misr Press, Cairo, n.d.).
  9. Al-Bakri, Abdul-Baqi and Al-Bashir, Zohair, Introduction to the Study of Law (Legal Library, Baghdad 2019).
  10. Al-Hakim, Abdul-Majid, Concise Explanation of Civil Law, vol 2: Effects of Obligations (Legal Library, Baghdad, n.d.).
  11. Al-Hakim, Abdul-Majid, Al-Bakri, Abdul-Baqi and Al-Bashir, Muhammad Taha, Concise Theory of Obligations in Iraqi Civil Law, vol 2: Effects of Obligations (Al-Atak Book Press, Cairo, n.d.).
  12. Al-Sanhouri, Abdel-Razzaq Ahmed, The mediator in Explanation of Civil Law, vol 2: Effects of Obligations (Dar Misr for Publishing and Distribution, Cairo 2020).
  13. Al-Zalmi, Mustafa Ibrahim, Judges Guide to Achieving Justice and Equality, 1st edn (Ihsan Publishing and Distribution, 2014).
  14. Bakr, Ismat Abdul-Majid, The General Theory of Obligation: Provisions of Obligation, 1st ed. (Zain Legal Library, Beirut, Lebanon, 2023).
  15. Hassan, Ahmed Ibrahim, The Purpose of Law (University Publications House, Alexandria, n.d.).
  16. Hassan, Dohan, Introduction to the Study of Law, vol 1 (University Press, Baghdad 1972).
  17. Hegazy, Abdul-Hay, Introduction to Legal Sciences According to Kuwaiti Law, vol 1 (Kuwait University Publications, 1972).
  18. Hussein, Ismail Namiq, Fundamentals of Legal Science (Al-Sanhoury Library, Beirut 2019).
  19. Manṣur, Muhammad Hussein, General Theory of Obligations: Rules of Obligations (New University House, Alexandria 2006).
  20. Saad, Nabil Ibrahim, Unnamed Guarantees in Private Law (Al-Maaref Establishment, Alexandria 2006).
  21. Saad, Nabil Ibrahim, Personal and Real Securities (New University House, Alexandria 2007).
  22. Saad, Nabil Ibrahim, General Theory of Obligations: Obligation provisions (New University House, Alexandria 2020).
  23. Sarour, Ahmed Fathi, Constitutional Legitimacy of Human Rights (Arab Renaissance House, Cairo 1995).
  24. Sultan, Anwar, General Theory of Obligations: Obligation provisions (New University House, Alexandria 2005).
  25. Tanagho, Samir, The General Theory of Law (Manshaat Al-Maaref, Alexandria 1974).
  26. Third: Theses:
  27. Khudair, Taha Sabaj, The Distinguished Legal Status of the Ordinary Creditor, Master’s Thesis, (College of Law, University of Al-Qadisiyah, 2024).
  28. Fourth: Legal Papers
  29. Al-Wakeel, Shams Al-Din, The Effect of Fraud on the Priority of Registration When Multiple Buyers Compete for One Property: An Attempt to Formulate a General Theory of Fraud (1959) 2.1 Journal of Legal and Economic Research.
  30. Shihab, Mufid, General Principles of Law as a Source of International Law (1967) 23 The Egyptian Journal of International Law.
  31. Fifth: Constitution and Statutes
  32. Justinian Code, tr Abdel-Aziz Fahmi, The Justinian Code, 1st edn (Egyptian Book House, Cairo 1946).
  33. Constitution of the Republic of Iraq (2005).
  34. Iraqi Civil Code, Law No. 40 of 1951.
  35. The Iraqi Enforcement Law No. 45 of 1980.
  36. Sixth: Judicial Collections
  37. Al-Mashahdi, Ibrahim, Legal Principles of the Court of Cassation, Civil Law Section, (Legal Research Center, Baghdad, 1988).
  38. https://alamiria.laalaws.com/Sections/Login, accessed on July 17, 2025.
  39. Seven: Websites
  40. FasterCapital, Creditor Equality: Ensuring Creditor Equality – The Principle of Pari Passu https://fastercapital.com/content/Creditor-equality--Ensuring-Creditor-Equality--The-Principle-of-Pari-Passu.html accessed 3 May 2025.
Download this PDF file
##submission.supplementaryFiles##

Statistics

Copyright and Licensing